Legion by Dan Abnett - Horus Heresy Book Review
July 13, 2019Most of you will know me from Twitter ( @oftheaett ) If not Hello! I'm Andy and I'm a UK based hobbyist and miniature ...
July 13, 2019
If not Hello!
I'm Andy and I'm a UK based hobbyist and miniature enthusiast - painter/ kit-basher and proud member of the #warmongers and #Warhammercommunity. Come say hi on my socials!
I'm Andy and I'm a UK based hobbyist and miniature enthusiast - painter/ kit-basher and proud member of the #warmongers and #Warhammercommunity. Come say hi on my socials!
The Emperor doesn't protect against Spoilers. You've been warned!
A Great War is coming, and it will engulf the Imperium of Man. The Space Marines of the Alpha Legion, the last and most secretive of all the Astartes brotherhoods, arrive on a heathen world to support the Imperial Army in a pacification campaign against strange and uncanny forces. But what drives the Alpha Legion? Can they be trusted, and what side will they choose when the Great War begins? Loyalties are put to the test, and the cunning schemes of an alien intelligence revealed in this latest instalment of the ground-breaking SF series by Dan Abnett, as the fate of mankind hangs in the balance.
Plot Summary
The Compliance Action on the world of Nurth is not going smoothly. Despite the leadership of the particularly prestigious and accomplished Lord Commander Teng Namatjira and the presence of ancient and elite Imperial Army regiments, the native inhabitants seem to be holding off the Imperial forces with relative ease.
Tired and stung by this turn of events, Adeptus Astartes reinforcement is requested, and granted. Astartes of the Alpha Legion, led by their Primarch, are tasked to the theatre. The Nurthene rebellion is doomed as a result, the majority of their armed forces bottled up in an enormous siege.
It becomes evident that the Alpha Legion do not operate as other Astartes Legions; they make great use of subterfuge, so much so that the Lord Commander was not aware of their presence and contribution to the campaign until they announced themselves. Subterfuge proves to be the order of the day in the Nurthene campaign, as it is discovered that a Xenos-augmented Human spy is loose in the theatre, attempting to orchestrate the complex plans of his masters...plans that included the manipulation of events that resulted in the Alpha Legion arriving on Nurth.
This spy, John Grammaticus, works for an organisation he knows as the Cabal, a group of Xenos species. This Cabal is dedicated to the excision of the Primordial Annihilator, Chaos. Aware of the coming Heresy, they believe that the Alpha Legion represent the last chance to save the galaxy from the predations of the Chaos powers. To this end, they confer with the Primarch of the Legion, Alpharius Omegon, and sway him/them to their viewpoint. In order for Chaos to perish, Horus must win the Heresy. In order for that to happen, the Alpha Legion must side with him.
Notable Characters
Primarchs
Alpharius Omegon — Primarch of the Alpha Legion
Alpha Legion
Ingo Pech — First Captain
Mathias Herzog — Captain of the 2nd Company
Sheed Ranko — Captain of the Lernaean Terminator Squad
Omegon — Lord of the Effrit Stealth Squad
Imperial Army
Teng Namatjira — Lord Commander
Honen Mu — Uxor of the Geno Five-Two Chiliad
Rukhsana Saiid — Uxor of the Geno Five-Two Chiliad
Hurtado Bronzi — Hetman of the Geno Five-Two Chiliad
Peto Soneka — Hetman of the Geno Five-Two Chiliad
Dinas Chayne — Bajolur-Captain of the Lucifer Blacks
Xenos
Gahet — member of the Cabal
Slau Dha — Eldar, member of the Cabal
G'Latrro — Xshesian, member of the Cabal
John Grammaticus, altered human, agent of the Cabal
Review
Hail Warmongers!
We're finally here! I've been waiting a long time to read Legion & boy was it worth it. A lot of you guys out there in the warmongers community (particularly on Twitter) were encouraging me to read this one & you guys had every right to. Legion is a definitely my favourite of the Horus Heresy so far & i'm sure most people will agree that it's a great read. It is Abnett after all!
As a rule of thumb, before I right these posts I try & do a bit of research to get an idea of public opinion on each book & for once I couldn't find a single bad word said about it. That is spare one comment regarding it's relevance to the HH, which posed the question of should it be a HH novel at all? My opinion? It deserves a place.
Let me expand on that - some of you will have read my review of Descent of Angels by Mitchel Scanlon in which I raised the same point. DOA missed mark in a lot of ways not because its a bad book or poorly written, in fact over all it was a great read, but as someone who really wanted to get my teeth into the Heresy & read all there way to read about it, i was left wanting. Now I know that's my personal opinion, but it seems to be widely accepted as one of the weaker novels & the main problem is relevance. DOA is intended as a precursor/origin story for the Dark Angles Primarch & his Legion but when you match up the events in the book to the Heresy, nothing ties it in with the rest, which for me was utterly frustrating. But does Legion suffer in the same way? No, I don't think so.
The biggest case against this point would be the plots main turning point. To me this really makes the book & is undoubtedly one of the most surprising plot points of the HH so far. For those of you who've read the book you'll probably know exactly which point I'm talking about. Towards the end of the book the Alpha legion are faced with a moral dilemma in which they are forced by the Cabal to decide whether to either intervene & prevent the Heresy (i.e Stand against Horus) or comply & assist Horus in his campaign. In the end the Alpha Legion's decision is revealed when they rebel against their allies in orbit above Nurth & decimate their fleet. This single action (set two standard years before the Heresy) sets in motion all that comes after it. Now given the nature of the Alpha Legion we simply will never know the true extent of their influence on the Heresy. But what we can do, is safely assume that nothing really happened with out their's or the Cabal's consent. Which to me proves relevance, but i'll let you guys decide for yourselves.
For me Legion breaks the mould in so many ways & in a move previously unseen in the Heresy, (i'm not counting Zahariel from DOA as he later became one) Abnett chooses to centre the book around a group of none Astartes characters. This technique of choosing a 'weakling' to me is one of the true hallmarks of his writing & is a simple yet effective way to bring perspective scale to any setting. I've said this before in my Horus Rising review (another Abnett, check it out!). Now, granted HR focused more on Loken (a Space Marine Legionnaire) but where possible, Abnett switched to a more 'mortal' character for perspective & he does this more often than any other writer in the series & its a real shame. Some try with token characters which stack up against the lead role e.g. Human 'sidekicks' like Kaleb from Flight of the Eisenstein, but these characters miss the mark for me.
This also works really well in this particular setting as to have the story told by an Alpha Legionnaire would be ridiculous. The whole appeal of the AL is that they are experts in subterfuge & secrecy which means if the book was written from their perspective nothing would be a surprise for the reader. It's actually one of the biggest gripes I have about books in general, suspense & intrigue keep the reader engaged & it applies to most genres. You wouldn't usually write a horror movie from the perspective of the killer/monster as you'd see what was coming a mile off, plus you wouldn't care for the victim. The same applies to Legion, it requires an outside perspective a victim if you like (in the is case Soneka).
Now let's move on to some honourable mentions -
Alpharius & Omegon - as Primarchs go they have kept my interest so far. I definitely want to see more, but not too much Obviously.
Peto Soneka - Great character, probably very unlikely to see him again but enjoyed following him around. Also anyone else get an Ibram Gaunt vibe from him?
Peto Soneka - Great character, probably very unlikely to see him again but enjoyed following him around. Also anyone else get an Ibram Gaunt vibe from him?
Hurtado Bronzi - a token character, typical fat sidekick really.
Dinas Chayne - all books need a dick character. Enjoyed him being ripped in half.
Slau Dha - I like the Eldar, as a big LOTR fan any Eldar/Elf character. Suits the Cabal theme well too.
I fell like that's all I have to say. I'd definitely recommend it & would probably reread this one, which for me is first in the Heresy series.
I give it a solid 9 out of 10
See you all next time guys - Andy
I fell like that's all I have to say. I'd definitely recommend it & would probably reread this one, which for me is first in the Heresy series.
I give it a solid 9 out of 10
See you all next time guys - Andy
About me
Hi I'm Andy and I'm a Miniature painter & hobby enthusiast.
I'm also a proud member of the #Warmongers community. #Warhammercommunity
Come say Hi on Twitter and Insta and please consider supporting me on my Ko-Fi page
People also read -
Tags
- Purge The Pit (3)
- guest post (2)
- heresy (2)
- horus (2)
- review (2)
- Fan Fiction (1)
- Tutorial (1)
- hobby guide (1)